Conversation

Notices

  1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd wow. Where to start. Centralization and standardization are two *totally* different things.

    Monday, 09-Oct-17 01:55:16 UTC from quitter.se
    1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd the fact that you would argue otherwise makes it clear that you are arguing backwards from an assumption...

      Monday, 09-Oct-17 01:56:06 UTC from quitter.se
      1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd ...rather than arguing towards whatever conclusion the data might actually lead to. #

        Monday, 09-Oct-17 01:56:50 UTC from quitter.se
        1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd the premise you are committed to is "centralization is good" > "cloud is good". I accept neither assumption

          Monday, 09-Oct-17 01:58:26 UTC from quitter.se
          1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd some level of coordination has benefits over none. For example, I support the development of (libre) standards.

            Monday, 09-Oct-17 01:59:24 UTC from quitter.se
            1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd  But history shows that centralization leads to fragile system, not to mention tyranny (eg USSR).

              Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:01:07 UTC from quitter.se
              1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd decentralized systems may be less "efficient", but they are *much* more resilient.

                Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:02:50 UTC from quitter.se
                1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd when the # goes down, it *all* goes down. Very few conditions could bring the entire # down

                  Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:03:16 UTC from quitter.se
                  1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd all that said, I do support campaigns for better regulation. For example:
                    http://qttr.at/1w75

                    Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:19:48 UTC from quitter.se
                    1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd but regulating an amorphous global phenomenon like the net is far from simple...

                      Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:20:36 UTC from quitter.se
                      1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd ...even without powerful industries who don't want better international regulation, and who block it at every turn

                        Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:22:39 UTC from quitter.se
                        1. @pnathan @natecull @cjd playing whack-a-mole with # and startups seems less effective longterm than providing replacements for them

                          Monday, 09-Oct-17 02:24:12 UTC from quitter.se