Conversation

Notices

  1. Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀ Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀

    If Posey got wings when redesigned as Fluttershy (because they needed another pegasus) Why Coulden't have Suprise/Pinkie Pie kept her wings instead of having given them to FLuttershy? After all, Rainbow Dash got wings on transition from Firefly.

    Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:41:02 UTC from web
    1. Eat me, I ain't telling you. Eat me, I ain't telling you.

      @cutesaurus even numbers of each race.

      Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:41:43 UTC from StatusNet iPhone
      1. Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀ Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀

        @quetzalcoatl if Pinkie got the wings instead of Fluttershy, there still would have been two of each race, tho.

        Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:43:22 UTC from web
    2. ★ ★

      @cutesaurus I think if Pinkie Pie had wings, all the fourth wall stuff wouldn't be as amusing.

      Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:42:37 UTC from web
      1. Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀ Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀

        @starshine @derpybronylikesrarity @artrageous Oh yes, I agree, but it seems silly when I really think about it.. mostly because of Fluttershy: it all works out in the end, of course, and Having Pinkie and Fluttershy as they are? I'd have it no other way. :P

        Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:48:24 UTC from web
        1. ★ ★

          @cutesaurus I think the most amusing bit of that is that Fluttershy lives on the ground and cares for animals, and Pinkie Pie can defy gravity and get anywhere pretty much instantly. It's like they switched which one had wings but didn't write the scripts to match. (I wonder if they'll touch on that in season 2 at all.)

          Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:50:48 UTC from web
    3. andrew B andrew B

      @cutesaurus I don't think Pinkie's fourth wall breaking would have been as fun if she were a pegasus.

      Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:42:47 UTC from web
      1. andrew B andrew B

        @derpybronylikesrarity actually scratch that, she probably would've broken the 4th wall even more

        Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:43:21 UTC from web
    4. Johanu Boulton Johanu Boulton

      @cutesaurus Not sure, it was a design decision, because Lauren Faust's original concept art for Pinkie Pie did have wings, so they were removed later. I expect they wanted to balance the number of types. In any case, I think she's funnier without wings, and you get comics like this: http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/227/5/4/pinkie_pie__s_hidden_talent_by_starlightspark-d46i137.jpg

      Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:44:37 UTC from web
    5. Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀ Leah Elizabeth Gnagy ♀

      @rotation I would, I would add more pony.

      Thursday, 25-Aug-11 19:55:17 UTC from web